Tim Bruening - Fab Academy 2016

Week #5 - 3D Scanning and 3D Printing

In the fifth week we examined the relationship between 3D Scanning and 3D Printing.  3D printing is an additive versus substractive technology.  That is we add material to make a part.  We typically start with an empty workspace or platform.  Material is then added layer by layer to make the part.  The layer thickness is the resolution of accuracy.  Very fine 3D printers have layers thicknesses in the micron range.  Subtractive processes start with a block of material and remove whatever is not needed to make the part.  Somewhat like a sculptor "seeing " a form in a block of granite or marble.

Here are the tasks we have for this week.

  • As a group test the design rules for whatever 3D printers we have.
  • Design and 3D print an object that could not be made by machining or other subtractive methods.
  • 3D scan an object and print it using one of the 3D printers we have.
  • Document the process and list any problems encountered.


  • As a group we tested the design rules for the 3D printers we have.


    As a group we looked at two different 3D printers.  A Dimension 1200es sst from Stratasys and a Maker Gear M2 Version 4.  I also looked at an XYZ DaVinci Jr 1.0 3D printer that I have at home.

    The Dimension 1200es SST

    smiley face
  • Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) 
  • ABSplus plastic
  • Minumum Wall Thickness 0.040"
  • Model wall thickness of .050" measured .051"
  • Can print up to 45 degrees without support material.  (See Test Part)
  • Always puts down a layer of support material.
  • Support material on the SST is soluble, BST support material is breakaway.
  • Layer Height selection is .010" or .013".  Our parts were made at .010".
  • Choice of fills = Solid, Sparse High Density and Sparse Low Density.
  • Choice of supports = Smart, Surround, Basic and Sparse.
  • Build size is 10" x 10" x 12".
  • Good with assemblies if minimum of .020" clearance is used.




  • Here is the tolerance test we ran on both the Dimension 1200es and the Maker Gear M2.

    The Maker Gear M2 outperformed the Dimension 1200es quite well although the Dimension orifinally cost 10 times more to buy.

    This definitely shows how much the technology has improved over the last eight years.




    smiley face



    The Maker Gear M2 Version 4

    smiley face


  • Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) 
  • ABSplus and PLA plastic
  • Minumum Wall Thickness 0.030"
  • Model wall thickness of .050" measured .049"
  • Can print up to 55 degrees without support material.  (See Test Part)
  • Does not have a separate support material.
  • It can create breakaway support material out of ABS or PLA.
  • Layer Height minimum is .004" (0.1 mm).
  • Choice of fills = 
  • Choice of supports = N/A.
  • Build size is 8" x 10" x 8".
  • Not good with assemblies..


  • The XYZ DaVinci Jr. 1.0


    smiley face

    smiley face


  • Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) 
  • PLA plastic
  • Minumum Wall Thickness 0.030"
  • Model wall thickness of .050" measured .051" on X-axis and .055" on Y-axis"
  • Can print up to ???? degrees without support material.  (See Test Part)
  • Does not have a separated support material.
  • It can create breakaway support material out of PLA.
  • Layer Height minimum is .004" (0.1 mm).
  • Choice of fills = 10%, 20%, 30%, 50%
  • Choice of supports = N/A.
  • Build size is 8" x 10" x 8".
  • Not good with assemblies..


  • Design and 3D print an object that could not be made by machining or other subtractive methods.



    I decided to make a series of nested cubes for my project. 


    Here is a screen capture of my design in SolidWorks.

    smiley face

    I saved the cubes as an .STL file and imported it into the Catalyst software for our Dimension 1200es printer.

    smiley face

    Here are a few picture of the finished cubes. The first photo shows the support material still on before going into the solvent tank.

    smiley face

    This next photo shows the cubes with the support material removed.

    smiley face



    3D scan an object and print it using one of the 3D printers we have.



    I used a Creaform GO!Scan 50 for this project.


    Here is a picture of the bear I chose to scan.


    smiley face

    Here is a picture of the bear after spray painting it gray.

    The gray paint helps in the scanning of the image.

    smiley face


    Here is a picture of the bear with dots placed all over.

    The dots help to realign the scan between captures.

    The scanner needs to see at least four dots to realign with the current image.



    smiley face

    In this picture I am scanning the bear.

    Notice the grid pattern on the bear and the computer screen in the background showing the current state of the scanned image.



    smiley face


    In this shot we see the final scanned image before cleaning up the file.




    smiley face


    Here are 2 images showing the background cleaned up in the top view.

    And the holes patched in the bottom view.



    smiley face


    Here is the .STL file shown in the Catalyst software for the Dimension 3D printer.


    smiley face


    Here we see the two bears after printing.

    One bear was saved with a 50% reduction in triangles from the original scan.

    It is nearly impossible to tell them apart.



    smiley face


    This is a screen capture of the bear using Retina Engrave software for the XYZ DaVinci Jr 1.0.



    smiley face

    This is the finished bear still in the XYZ DaVinci Jr 1.0




    smiley face


    We also have a NextEngine 3D laser scanner.



    smiley face


    Document the process and list any problems encountered.


    I did not have any problems this week.  I am familiar with 3D scanning.  I did however learn a lot about our new Creaform scanner and how to use it.




    Tim's 3D files:

    *.STL files from scanning and/or SolidWorks.

  • 3 Nested Cubes
  • Bear with 50 percent triangles
  • Thickness test for XYZ DaVinci Printer
  • Test Print for Dimension 1200es and Maker Gear M2


  • *.Sldprt files from SolidWorks.

  • Thickness test for XYZ DaVinci Printer
  • Nested cubes for SolidWorks.



  •   Back to index